Part of the openDemocracy Network

The Damian Green Affair


A Very British Arrest: Laura Sandys on the precedent of her father's 1939 experience.


One reason why the police are dangerous, undemocratic and stupid: Anthony Barnett condemns an attack on democracy.


Questioned by the Met: An MP's experience: Tony Clarke on the crucial differences with his own case.


A Constitutional Failure: The Damian Green case highlights the need for a written constitution, argues Tom Griffin.

Immigration islands


The Return of Enoch: Enoch Powell's repatriation agenda must not be rehabilitated, argues Sunder Katwala.


The ugly economics of immigration: Paul Kingsnorth on why the left is out of step with working class interests.


Immigration and the Politics of Resentment: Shamser Sinha suggests the real problem is a politics that turns neighbour against neighbour.

A neoliberal kingdom


Britain’s neo-liberal state: The financial crisis exposes the need for democratic modernisation, argue Gerry Hassan and Anthony Barnett.


Sortition and public policy




A major new series from Imprint Academic on the use of randomisation in education, politics and other public policy areas. Special discount prices for OurKingdom and openDemocracy readers.

MODERN LIBERTY



Digital Privacy Wars: Guy Aitchison flags up a debate on the threat business poses to digital privacy


The Stalker State: Phil Booth of No2ID on the proposed Comms database


Say 'No' to 42 days: Sign Amnesty's petition against extending pre-charge detention


What do we do now?: Anthony Barnett assesses the stakes for for liberals and radicals in David Davis's campaign against the erosion of rights and liberties


The Abundance of Caution: an authoritative essay by Anthony Barnett sets out the case against 42 Days

Labour After Brown

The next left -Life after the Labour Party: Gerry Hassan sees a historic opportunity for the emergence of a post-New Labour left.

Scottish Labour, where's the coffee?: Gerry Hassan assesses the prospects for Scottish Labour and its new leader.

Lesson for the Left from Chile to Britain: Hassan Akram offers a global perspective on Labour's malaise.

From Milibland to Johnson land?: Jeremy Gilbert argues for Labour without neo-liberalism.

Magical thinking on Britishness: Anthony Barnett critiques Liam Byrne on fraternity.

Rule of law at risk: Geoffrey Bindman calls for a turn away from the marketisation of government.

A new Bill of Rights for Britain?: Guy Aitchison analyses Parliament's proposed new Bill of Rights.

Miliband - by our rights we will know you: Claire O'Brien puts forward a new progressive vision for Labour.

Recapturing liberal Britain: David Marquand challenges Labour's constitutional orthodoxy.

Miliband and the Liberal Democrats: James Graham on the case for realignment.

What is Labour's British story?: Writing from Scotland, Gerry Hassan widens the OurKingdom debate on Labour's future.

This is not Brown's crisis but Britain's: David Marquand says social democracy is bust and Britain may be too.

The Challenges for Miliband's Progressive Fusion: Fabian Society head Sunder Katwala responds to David Miliband.

England Awakes?

England, Britain and multiculturalism: an OurKingdom exchange

A mild awakening?, England's turn? by David Goodhart

Recent comments

Navigation

delicious | digg | reddit | newsvine | furl | google | yahoo | technorati | diigolet

Syndicate content

A parliamentary pantomime

Stuart Weir, 4 - 12 - 2008
delicious | digg | reddit | newsvine | furl | google | yahoo | technorati | diigolet

Stuart Weir (London, Democratic Audit): A delicious irony, between the elaborate pantomime of the Commons’ tradition of independence enacted once again for the royal opening and the abject reality of the House’s current weakness, another aspect of this cruelly made evident by the Speaker’s pitiful performance.

However his inadequacies have already been clearly signalled in previous episodes of doubt and confusion.  What hasn’t been discussed is the foolish and partisan way in which the House now chooses the Speaker, whose charade of refusal fails to mask the attraction of the office for MPs who are past it (or have never been with it) for a prestigious perk. It is a national version of the yearly processions of mayors being crowned in town and county halls around the world, and operates broadly on the same principle of buggin’s turn.  It hardly seems to matter at local level, though it is often an unnecessarily costly and pompous affair, and frequently unedifying. I still remember a drunk mayor in Hackney tumbling into a swimming pool on the occasion of a show house opening.

It is of course a truism that “Parliament” doesn’t exist as a body, nor even the Commons, except when MPs’ salaries and conditions are being discussed.  It is a truism that parliamentary sovereignty represents executive sovereignty in action, even in such matters as Parliament’s legislative programme and rules.  The governing principle is, “the government must get its business through”.

Even so, you would at least hope that MPs, when going through the ponderous act of electing a Speaker would cast their votes on the basis of merit and a proper sense of the significance of the idea that the Speaker should be in the front line to defend and improve Parliament.  I have worked in several sub-Saharan African parliaments where this is how Speakers interpret their role, relying on the Westminster tradition and the 1688 Bill of Rights. Indeed, Cyril Ndebele, the Speaker in the Zimbabwe Parliament until 2001, defied Robert Mugabe by invoked the Bill of Rights to defend an MP who had called for the President  “to go” in the parliamentary chamber.

Stuart Weir's blog | email this blogpdf version | quote
delicious | digg | reddit | newsvine | furl | google | yahoo | technorati | diigolet
 

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

owly said:

Fri, 2008-12-05 21:39

Lay the blame where it belongs. When Speaker Martin was elected it was, by convention, the turn of a Tory to take the chair. The massed ranks of morons, which make up the Labour benches, would no more vote for a Tory for Speaker than they would to cut their own over inflated pay. We now see the results of their arrogance and contempt for the traditions of Parliament. Not fit for purpose would describe the vast majority of Labour MPs. It also describes Speaker Martin. 

reply | email this commentquote

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><b> <i> <br> <p> <div> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
More information about formatting options

In Pictures


They say about OK

"the ever-stimulating OpenDemocracy"
Ekklesia

"See OurKingdom to keep up"
South Belfast Diary

"...an essential guide to understanding the dynamic constitutional situation..."
Peter Oborne

"...becoming a daily read for me."
Iain Dale

"To make sense of it all, check out OurKingdom..."
Matthew d'Ancona

"Worth a look...it is, however, recommended by Matthew d'Ancona."
The Wardman Wire

"Fast becoming the best political website around"
Tom Waterhouse, CEP

"...attracting energy from a range of contributors."
thenextwave

"...looks very promising..."
The England Project

"The excellent new OurKingdom blog from OpenDemocracy..."
The Green Ribbon

"On the internet, I keep in touch with openDemocracy, a website on global current affairs, and its useful offshoot, OurKingdom"
Andreas Whittam-Smith

"thanks to the fine folk at OurKingdom, (who manage to communicate a variety of perspectives in the way that only a decent group blog can)"
Nostalgia For the Future