If under stress of circumstance individuals have made any promise to the enemy, they are bound to keep their word even then.
If under stress of circumstance individuals have made any promise to the enemy, they are bound to keep their word even then.
NavigationMost discussed this month |
![]() |
A quick update from Brussels: criteria for successElsewhere on openDemocracy
Internet access within the European Parliament building has not been as easy to get hold of as you might think, hence the lack of posts over this weekend. Having sat in on small group discussions, spoken to various organisers and participants, and seen more about how the whole thing works, I'll hope to report in full over the next few days, having written up my extensive notes. Liveblogging, however, has sadly proved impossible... Initial impression? It's certainly an interesting experiment - though I'm not sure if a group of nearly 400 people isn't just too big for this to really work on a practical level. Which creates additional problems - because much smaller than that, the arguments for representativeness (on which more over the next few days) become far, far less convincing. In the press conference I'm currently sitting in, Professor Fishkin has laid out his three criteria for success: 1) Is it representative? 2) Is it deliberative? 3) Will decision-makers listen to the results? Fishkin seems hopeful, noting that the participants seem to be representative, that discussions took place throughout the last few days, and noting that both the Bulgarian Prime Minister (a speaker at this afternoon's final plenary meeting) and Jens-Peter Bonde, the Danish MEP, have become proponents of deliberative polling, even though one is very pro-EU, the other somewhat anti-. He seems happy, but is his satisfaction justified? As the results of the final poll are collated, I'll do my best to number-crunch... Post new comment |
![]() |
The World
|
Recent comments
4 hours 50 min ago
6 hours 30 min ago
10 hours 50 min ago
12 hours 1 min ago
13 hours 14 min ago
13 hours 26 min ago
13 hours 35 min ago
13 hours 50 min ago
14 hours 7 min ago
15 hours 44 min ago